Work for Sinn Féin to do before “Border Poll”

Today would have been Scottish Independence Day, had a quarter of a million people changed their mind upon entering the polling station in 2014.

Meanwhile, after the DUP’s predictable sectarian dog whistle that the First Minister must be a Unionist, we then had Sinn Féin’s predictable call for a “Border Poll”.

Yet this only draws attention to the fact that it was the DUP’s negotiating failure which made the First Ministership an issue; and that it is Sinn Féin which fails to come up with a strategy for any form of “United Ireland”.

In Scotland’s equivalent independence referendum, the SNP produced a document of over 700 pages explaining how an independent Scotland would operate. Where is Sinn Féin’s equivalent for a “United Ireland”?!

The 1998 Agreement, as amended ever so slightly in 2006, was an extremely delicate balancing act – the people of Northern Ireland’s British identity was reflected by remaining within the UK; their Irish identity was reflected through the right to Irish identity/citizenship and cross-border bodies; and their common regional identity was reflected by devolved institutions, themselves reflecting the traditional communal divide through power-sharing. Anything which tampers with this balance threatens the whole thing – like taking just one leg off an average four-legged table renders the whole table useless.

Removing the British aspect by leaving the UK would collapse the table. What exactly is the plan to restore the balance in its absence? How realistically could it be brought about? What precisely is the point?! (And all of this is before how we manage the legal implications, overcome the economic challenges, and establish new ways of securing the place.)

If the DUP wants the First Minister, let us hear precisely how it matters. And if Sinn Féin wants a “Border Poll”, let us see the detail.

Neither party is up to the challenge. Small wonder they deliver nothing but gridlock government. It’s time for change.

Advertisements

One thought on “Work for Sinn Féin to do before “Border Poll”

  1. The Scottish referendum had a sort of clarity that you don’t have in both the European referendum and an Irish border poll question. Clarity over who and how the region in question is governed on both sides of the arguement.

    Vote for Scottish Independence was a mandate for the SNP to govern the nation, a vote against let Westminster continue to rule Scotland.

    Yes you get Salmond, No you get Cameron, Miliband or Clegg.

    Voting for Leave or Remain doesn’t change the government,, it may not even change the Prime Minister or cabinet. The DUP are not even in the mix at Westminster and they may have to govern a pro-EU voting Northern Ireland during a Brexit. It would be interesting to see if there’s a divergence between what the people want and what the DUP want.

    Also since SF want to govern in the “Six Counties” but not the “Twenty Six” counties, surely they have effectively sacrificed their right to be leading an all-Ireland nationalist campaign on the border poll question to whatever group could position as governing a “32 county” Ireland.

    Both groups need to realise that they will need to manage a difficult transition period, risks and reforms needed to get what they want. They both need to plan for taking opportunities before they become victims of circumstances.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: