For good government, NI needs to overcome basic myths

Nowhere else in the world does healthcare become politicised in this way” said one recent contributor to a BBC debate.

In one line, she defined what is so dysfunctional about Northern Ireland “politics”. We have a bizarre notion of what “politics” is, and how exceptional we are.

Of course, healthcare is politicised in every democracy. What is more, that is exactly how it should be. Why on earth would it not be politicised? What on earth do we think we elect politicians for, if it is not to make decisions about healthcare, education, infrastructure and so on?

Every time the Assembly debates flags or a Council debates sporting invites, the coverage is vast. When they debate “real issues” – healthcare, education, infrastructure and the rest – it is more limited. Every time, numerous people comment how ridiculous it is that symbols and identity get such coverage and real issues (like, er, healthcare, education and infrastructure) do not.

Yet when we move on to those “real issues”, we then have this bizarre notion that they should not, in fact, be “politicised”. So in fact, logically, politicians should spend all their time talking about identity, is that right?

The comment also spoke to a bizarre exceptionalism; a belief that somehow everything is automatically different (and inferior) in Northern Ireland. There are many more such examples. How many times, for example, do we hear about our “unique” ability to mess up capital projects (even though Germany – yes, Germany – has an airport opening this year over a decade late)? More specifically, how many times, for example, do we hear about how Belfast Airport is “uniquely” not directly connected to the rail network (nor are Dublin, Cardiff, London-Luton, Bristol, Berlin-Tegel… or indeed most airports, actually)? We even now have the “most dangerous prison in the UK” (even though it is considerably less dangerous than average on almost every relevant measure). Everywhere else in the world is apparently full of geniuses who build everything on time, link up infrastructure perfectly, make prisons universally peaceful, and of course magically “not politicise” stuff that we elect politicians to deal with. Northern Ireland uniquely fails in every regard (despite the world-class Titanic Belfast centre forming part of the fastest rising tourist numbers in the UK, the most punctual train service in the UK, by far the lowest prison population in the UK, and healthcare only blighted politically by the fact it isn’t politicised because everyone is simply populist about it…)

Facts, eh?

It is time we came to terms with what “politics” is (“balance of powers/interests”, to give it its very original meaning), and with the fact that, when we do, we will look much like any other post-industrial society in Western Europe.


5 thoughts on “For good government, NI needs to overcome basic myths

  1. I agree mostly, though I don’t like the archaic term post-industrial. As far as I’m concerned post industrial society means a retirement home …and even then.

  2. korhomme says:

    Ah, Berlin’s new airport. Not a tale of German efficiency. They turned the lights on there a while back, only to discover that there wasn’t an ‘off’ switch.

  3. E Smith says:

    Shortly after returning to NI I started to follow politics here because I needed to make a decision on how to vote in the election. I expected the debates to be on similar topics to those in England i.e. jobs, the Health Service etc. and was astonished that they were about parades, flags, the Irish language and various other minor issues. Even more surprising was that any time the topics of the economy and job creation were mentioned the person, irrespective of which political party they belonged to, was abruotly dismissec and the debate retuned to the usual subject matter.

    There appears to be a collective lack of confidence affecting the people of N I, hence the reason they think they have unique problems or are not good enough. You are right, Ian, in many instances they have no need to feel this as the train service is good, the Titanic experience is superb and eating out here is easily as good, if not better, than in rest of the UK. i could provide many other examples.

    However, where NI is let down badly is in leadership, not just in politics but in other areas. For example, i have observed that workers are often not appreciated and intimidated by their bosses and are scared to stand up for themselves and the public sector frequently sends out rude and often intimidating correspondence, I have heard a lot of people here say that it’s best to turn a blind eye and ignore what’s happening and they clearly are scared of the consequences of speaking out, This is not something I can recall hearing in at least the last 20 years in England,

    People in leadership in politics, the public sector and in other postions of importance are hanging on to their positions and doing their damnest to resist change. However, I am starting to detect some small signs of people fighting back. The sooner this happens the better for the future of this country.

  4. Luton Airport Parkway – train station at Luton Airport

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: