Public Sector Unions’ lack of solidarity with poor disappointing

I was unsurprised by the wide-ranging response to my blog post two weeks ago entitled “Defending the Public Sector isn’t Defending the Poor“. What was interesting was that not a single negative response provided any evidence whatsoever to challenge the point of the piece – inherent within the title!

There is of course a case for defending the Public Sector per se – and indeed the Public Sector Unions should do it. This very blog has argued that too much administration is being foisted on to teachers; the treatment hospital nurses are expected to put up with is outrageous; and most notably of all all workers should have a reasonable expectation not to be injured at work, and that very much includes police officers. Contrary to some of the nonsensical abuse which followed the piece, I have in fact argued consistently for removing administrative burden from teachers and increasing their pay (relative to other workers); for fundamentally re-assessing the requirements placed upon nurses particularly with reference to the burden of proof during complaints; and for politicians to stand up for the basic right of all public sector workers to be safe in the line of duty.

However, the fact is (and Public Sector Unions don’t seem too keen on facts) that Northern Ireland suffered a 10% real-terms decline in living standards during the Great Recession, more so than anywhere else in the UK. It is unreasonable to the point of being outrageous that anyone would think that they can get away without contributing to the very real burden this has caused us all.

Yet, thus far, the fact is the brunt has been borne by the private and voluntary sector suffering job losses, reduced hours and lower wages. At the same time (and note this is not an attack, it is a fact – let us be clear about the distinction) no compulsory redundancies and no pay cuts of any kind in any part of the public sector.

Despite this, no one is suggesting compulsory redundancies or pay cuts for the public sector – a remarkable piece of solidarity with public sector workers on the part of the rest of us. The Assembly has merely decided that, given the appalling economic circumstances towards for which absolutely everyone else has suffered, public sector workers should perhaps need to save more for their pension in order that we do not all collectively have hand over a £1 billion out of the NI public services budget during the next Assembly term.

The shocking lack of solidarity shown towards the working poor (almost universally to be found among the two thirds of workers in the private and voluntary sector) by Public Sector Unions will not be swiftly forgotten. Alongside business organisations’ appalling failure to advocate swift moves towards higher wages in the private sector, the Unions’ protectionist attitude of a single sector at the expense of the rest of us is a prime factor in “Sector Wars”. We should be thankful that, however reluctantly, the Assembly did what was right so that everyone pays their way in our recovery from a Great Recession in which £1 in every £10 has essentially disappeared from us.

I changed the title in response to an entirely reasonable point made by a Twitter correspondent – the type of constructive criticism I wish I had more of on this blog!


3 thoughts on “Public Sector Unions’ lack of solidarity with poor disappointing

  1. Iain Oregano says:

    I don’t know if you’re necessarily the right man to be making these arguments

    • And YET AGAIN someone responds unable to deal with the facts so he tries a nice “ad hominem” attack instead.

      Which was rather my point.

      I spent two years working in the inner-city on the biggest poverty research project in Northern Ireland. My wife has spent ten years working in the inner-city directing the largest regeneration project of its kind in the British Isles.

      Not the right man, huh?

      I actually care about tackling poverty – unlike most people who like to spout about it but really want nothing to change. We’ll come to that tomorrow…

  2. Iain Oregano says:

    More think tank politicians. Just was society ordered…

    Seriously though, you told us all here that you hadn’t been paying tax over the past few years, ergo people in the public sector are hardly going to be persuaded of a need to reform and desaturate by someone who hasn’t contributed to the economy.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: