NI’s problem is its “imposed solution”

Since 1972 the UK Government has spoken of the “Irish dimension” to any “solution” in Northern Ireland; and the Irish Government has acquiesced to the Principle of Consent, effectively placing Northern Ireland within the UK.

What is interesting about this is that no political party has adopted this (UK sovereignty with power-sharing and an Irish dimension) as its preferred constitutional outcome. Indeed, of all candidates standing for election in the history of Northern Ireland, I can think of only one who expressly and overtly supported it as his preferred solution – namely me!

This is part of the problem. Although most people in Northern Ireland are prepared to tolerate this “solution”, at least temporarily, almost no one here actually supports it. This is, partially at least, at the heart of our on-going difficulties – the vast bulk of the population continues to believe that, one day, magically, another “solution” much more to their own liking will become apparent and acceptable to all. At some time, however, we all need to accept this is nonsense – it won’t. What we have now is the answer to the “Constitutional Question”, whether people (really) like it or not.

The reality is the two Governments’ position has not changed in nearly half a century, nor is it likely to. In 1973, 1982, 1993, 1998, 2006 and 2010 they have attempted deals (with wildly varying degrees of success) based on this “solution”. We have now, in 2013, arrived at the position that both Governments take this “solution” as so obviously self-evident, that neither is paying real attention to Northern Ireland at all – which is a sign of progress of sorts, but is not necessarily a good thing.

So is it time a significant bulk of the population were prepared to stand up and say “You know what, this is the solution”? Would that make a significant difference?


3 thoughts on “NI’s problem is its “imposed solution”

  1. harryaswell says:

    You know what? – It comes as no surprise to me that you never got elected with ideas such as those! – You are dealing with “real” people here, never forget that! Until ALL parties accept we do have to forgive, forget, and accept each others cultural differences, there will be NO changes in attitude from any party, despite all the bleatings in the world to the contrary from Sinn Fein, and certainly not from Alliance!

  2. Ian, I thought this was the de facto position of Alliance. Though even party founder Oliver Napier was opposed to the Council of Ireland dimension when mooted as part of the 1973 Sunningdale Agreement.

    Although Alliance in theory is agnostic about Irish unification, in practice it has always defended sole-UK sovereignty status of Northern Ireland. I’ve argued for a Northern Ireland-first policy, but one logic of that is UDI (something neither Unionists nor Nationalist want).

    • As you know (and is obvious from the piece), I am entirely with you on that point.

      Nevertheless, I cannot find any reference post-1998 to the Party expressly saying that. That said, when I said it in 2009, no one quibbled.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: